I'll admit I'm cynical to the point where it's a sin when it comes to this issue. But I'm tired of the phrase, "don't put God in a box" (and all similar phrases). It's a phrase I used to enjoy throwing around, especially to my Dad when I was home from College in the mid 90's. It's funny how much ones God view, world view and theology can evolve and change as you grow spiritually. I'm usually very guarded with whom I choose to share ideas and thoughts on prayer and how God might be working in the world today. That being said I'm getting ready to share some of these very thoughts with whoever chooses to read this posting. Typical responses I tend to get when I share personal ideas about prayer and God's activity in the world are, "you limit God," "your putting God in a box," "God wants us to ask him for everything and anything," "God can't give you what you don't ask for."
I have a problem with the "laundry list" or "top 10 ten" list kind of prayer. Not that it is wrong I just think it may not be the kind of prayer God really desires from me. I struggle with how exactly God intervenes in the world, particularly with regard to physical healing. In fact, this may come as a shock to you but I never prayed once for God to physically heal Rachel and NOBODY loves her or wanted her well more than I did. I just don't believe that sort of prayer is where I should spend my time. People get sick and die of all sorts of diseases all the time. I'll do my best to organize these thoughts as best I can.
I cannot just accept easy answers or explanations to complex issues. I do not believe God manipulates free will. If He did than He would cease to be a relational God and that is the one thing God will never do. He will not break covenant, meaning He will always remain relational in nature. Since I believe He does not manipulate or override ones free will there will always be drunk driving accidents, murder, terrorism, etc... regardless of prayer. That is precisely the reason I cannot get myself to pray for "safe travel," because I believe in doing that, I'm asking God to disregard another's free will. For example, an individual has the ability to make the decision to consume too much alcohol and get behind the wheel. When this happens there is a good chance (because of free will) that people will be harmed and/or killed.
I find it interesting that the only time Jesus cries (that we know of) is when He is asked to bring someone (Lazarus) back to life. I personally believe this caused Jesus much grief because He knew and realized just what He was calling Lazarus back from. By the way, Lazarus still eventually died! So in praying for physical healing aren't we just asking God to delay the natural course of action that was instituted after sin entered into the world? I also want to point out here that Jesus did not come to hand out a miracle every time someone had a need. Did Jesus heal, yes. Jesus was moved with compassion when he saw people hurting. However, we must realize most people Jesus didn't heal. Most people read John’s narrative about the sick man at the pool in Bethzatha and say, "PRAISE THE LORD, JESUS HEALS!!!!" I read Johns words and say, MOST people he didn't heal." Jesus walks by the pool with dozens if not hundreds of sick people and heals one. So most He doesn't heal. What’s the point...It's a big one. Jesus didn't come to heal. The gospel is NOT about how comfortable your life is. It's about putting your faith and trust in a man named Jesus, who never had a home, who didn't have many possessions and who suffered his entire life.
Another aspect I struggle with is when people are inconsistent. For example, week in and week out in bible class and church we pray for people. Relatives, friends, family, loved ones, etc... We pray for cancer to be removed, pregnancies to go well and pain to be relieved. However, just about every church I have been a part of has had a member or members that are blind, paralyzed, mentally handicap, etc... And those people are never prayed over that God may miraculously heal them in our presence. In fact, there is a deaf man that recently placed membership at the church I worship at. He has been attending for several months if not a year. I have NEVER seen his name on a prayer list and to my knowledge he is never prayed over so that his hearing may be restored. Yet, every week we pray (and believe) that God will heal all other types of illnesses. I see this as a strange contradiction. IF Jesus was in the business of healing peoples physical ailments and we really believed that...why isn't the deaf man being prayed for???
So by this point you may be thinking what in the world do I pray for. Prayer is a HUGE part of my spiritual walk; in fact, I like to think I have a very healthy prayer life and communication with God. However, I prefer to spend time in silence before God, I chose to meditate on his word rather than pray a "laundry" or "top 10 list." I find it much more meaningful (and relevant) to spend time in solitude and ask that God would form and shape me more into the image of his Son than to ask for my "cold" to go away or my bank account to miraculously grow.
I've decided to put God back in the box for awhile. And in the box, I hope to find some quiet time to read and be transformed by God's prayer book, the Psalms. In the box, where it is quiet, I will strain to hear the voice of God and to do my best to be discerning. In the box, where all the noise is filtered out, I will pray and listen and hopefully be transformed into the person God intended me to be. In the box, I will find peace as I practice the spiritual disciple of solitude that has sustained so many for so long. In the box, I will realize that God is not my "genie in a bottle" but be reminded that He made himself flesh and dwelt among us and experienced pain, illness, hurt, and most of all abandonment. Jesus wanted a prayer answered so badly that he cursed God when it wasn't answered, "my God, my God, why have you forsaken me??? And God said nothing. Thank God for his silence, for if He would have answered that prayer...there would be no Christians at all.
The house is quiet, my wife and daughter are asleep...I think I'll head to my box.